Asthma is a chronic lung condition that causes episodes of difficulty breathing, typically triggered by environmental allergens or physical activity. It comes in two forms: restrictive and obstructive. Knowing the differences between these types of asthma can help inform your approach to treatment and prognosis.
Table of Contents
What is Restrictive and Obstructive Asthma?
Restrictive asthma, also known as “fixed airflow obstruction” asthma, is defined by a decreased ability to take in air as a result of a decline in lung function.
Although the airways are not clogged, the lung tissue is injured, making it more difficult to expand the lungs and take in air. This kind of asthma is less prevalent and is frequently caused by sarcoidosis or interstitial pulmonary disease.
Obstructive asthma, often known as “reversible airflow obstruction” asthma, is characterised by airway blockage that makes breathing difficult.
Because of inflammation and mucus accumulation, the airways constrict, making it harder for air to pass in and out of the lungs. This is the most prevalent kind of asthma, and it is frequently induced by allergens, irritants, or viral infections.
Read: Learn About the Different Sleep Stages and How Many There Are
Treatment for both types of asthma typically involves medications such as bronchodilators and corticosteroids to help open up the airways and reduce inflammation, as well as lifestyle changes such as avoiding triggers and monitoring symptoms.
Symptoms of Restrictive and Obstructive Asthma
The symptoms of restrictive and obstructive asthma can be similar, but they also have some differences.
Symptoms of restrictive asthma may include:
- Shortness of breath, especially with exertion
- Fatigue
- Chest tightness
- Rapid breathing
- Reduced ability to take deep breaths
- Reduced lung function, as measured by spirometry
Symptoms of obstructive asthma may include:
- Wheezing, a whistling sound when breathing
- Shortness of breath, especially at night or early in the morning
- Chest tightness
- Coughing, especially at night or early in the morning
- Difficulty breathing
- Rapid breathing
Both types of asthma can also cause symptoms such as difficulty sleeping, difficulty exercising, and difficulty with daily activities.
It is important to note that not everyone with asthma will have all of these symptoms, and the severity and frequency of symptoms can vary from person to person.
The Difference Between Restrictive and Obstructive Asthma
The main difference between restrictive and obstructive asthma is the cause of their symptoms.
Restrictive asthma often results from scarring or inflamed tissue, while obstructive asthma occurs due to bronchial constriction or obstruction caused by inflammation in the airways.
So, Which Type of Asthma is More Severe, Restrictive or Obstructive?
It is difficult to tell whether form of asthma is more severe, restrictive or obstructive, because they are two distinct types of asthma with distinct origins and symptoms.
Both forms of asthma may be severe, and the severity of asthma varies widely across individuals. The severity of asthma can be determined by factors such as the frequency and severity of symptoms, the degree of lung function impairment, and the impact on daily living.
But obstructive asthma is usually more severe than restrictive, as it can cause airway constriction which makes breathing difficult.
Diagnosing and Treating Restrictive and Obstructive Asthma
Assessing whether someone has restrictive or obstructive asthma is important in determining the most effective treatment.
A pulmonologist will use specialized equipment to measure the lung volume and airflow rate of a patient, which helps determine whether the problem is caused by an obstruction or if it’s more severe than that.
Depending on the type of asthma and severity, treatment may include medications like inhalers, bronchodilators, and steroids; lifestyle changes such as avoiding triggers; or even surgery for severe cases.
Long-Term Management of Both Types of Asthma
The long-term management of restrictive and obstructive asthma involves a combination of medications and lifestyle changes to help control symptoms and prevent exacerbations.
The primary objective of restricted asthma therapy is to enhance lung function and minimise inflammation. Corticosteroids and other immunosuppressive medicines are commonly used in treatment, as is physical therapy to assist preserve lung function.
The main goal of treatment for obstructive asthma is to reduce inflammation and open up the airways to improve breathing. This can be done through a combination of medications, including:
- Long-term control medications, such as inhaled corticosteroids, leukotriene modifiers, and long-acting bronchodilators, which are taken daily to help control inflammation and keep the airways open
- Quick-relief medications, such as short-acting bronchodilators, which are taken as needed to relieve symptoms during an asthma attack
Lifestyle changes are also important in managing both types of asthma, including:
- Avoiding triggers, such as allergens, irritants, and certain medications
- Monitoring symptoms and keeping track of peak flow (the measurement of how well air moves out of your lungs)
- Maintaining a healthy diet, regular exercise, and proper sleep
- Quitting smoking
- Working with a healthcare provider to create an asthma action plan
It is essential to work with a healthcare provider to create a customized treatment plan that works best for you. Regular follow-up appointments are important to monitor the progress and make adjustments to the treatment plan as needed.